Russian Language Marketplaces Remain Drivers of Crypto Drug Sales: TRM Labs Report

One, casual drug buyers are shifting away from the darknet to make their purchases, while larger buyers are simply buying more per purchase. For comparison, most midsize companies operating in the US earn between $10 million and $1 billion annually. Both Agartha and Cartel earned enough revenue within the 35-week period we tracked them to be characterized as midsize companies, earning $91.6 million and $32.3 million, respectively. Other markets like Aurora, DeepMart, and WhiteHouse were also on track to reach the revenue of a midsize company if given a full year to earn. Cointelegraph covers fintech, blockchain and Bitcoin bringing you the latest crypto news and analyses on the future of money.

• DWMs are also communication platforms, where users can meet and chat with other users either directly—using Whatsapp, phone, or email—or through specialised forums.
• You’ll get stolen credit cards, remote desktop account info, personal details, and various logs.
• Specifically, we show how the networks of multihomers and seller-to-seller interactions can shed light on the resilience of the dark market ecosystem against external shocks.
• This data enables account takeover attacks across email, social media, and corporate tools.
• This not only helps protect your identity but also contributes to your overall cybersecurity in the digital age.
• Another key factor driving the growth of darknet markets is the diversification of products and services.

The Emergence of Marketplaces on the Darknet

During 2016 and 2017, AphaBay becomes the dominant market (see Fig. 3), polarizing sellers around its own ecosystem, such that the fraction of multisellers decreases to 10% of all sellers until its closure. Then, after operation Bayonet, the number of sellers in all categories and multisellers significantly drops, as shown in Fig. Notably, the number of multisellers suffers the largest drop of \(-99\%\) by the end of the first quarter of 2018. Interestingly, while the other categories of sellers show signs of recovery relative to their previous levels, the number of multisellers remains low after that shock (see Supplementary Information Section S4). The empty point on the multiseller median income line demarcates the quarter with only two multisellers. After that quarter, their number remains small, which is represented by the dashed line.

Types of Illicit Goods and Services

Additionally, where non-compliant cash out points are facilitating the movement of illicit funds from DNMs, regulators and law enforcement may take action to disrupt activity at the cash out point itself. For example, concurrent with the takedown of Hydra was the sanctioning of Garantex, the Moscow-based exchange that made multiple transactions with Hydra-linked addresses. Established in 2022, BidenCash is known for trading personal identifiable information (PII) and engaging in fraud-related activities.

Market operations

The future of darknet trade looks promising, with ongoing advancements poised to further enhance the user experience. The starting point for this paper is the identification of U2U networks around DWMs. We analyse 40 DWMs for the time period spanning from June 18, 2011 to January 31, 2021. Our dataset covers all major DWMs that have ever existed, as identified by the European Monitoring Centre, Europol, the World Health Organization, and independent researchers24,25,26. Our analysis focuses on Bitcoin – the most popular cryptocurrency both on DWMs27,28 and in the regulated economy29,30.

What are onion sites and dark web websites?

The horizontal bars represent each market lifetime, i.e., the time when the market becomes active until its closure, and is colored according to the market’s monthly trading volume in USD. In the vertical axis, markets are in the chronological order of their launch date, although for some markets the activity effectively starts after the launch date (e.g., AlphaBay). Buyers simultaneously active on multiple markets also play the role of connectors in the ecosystem. Therefore, we analyse the temporal network where nodes are the active markets and an edge between the nodes represents the number of multibuyers between them, what we henceforth call the multibuyer network. The structural change seen in the multiseller network is not observed in the multibuyer network, as show in Fig.

Size of listings

However, the markets are dominated by things like illegal drugs, explicit content, pirated files, hacking services, and stolen personal information, among others. It’s one of the largest darknet markets that launched in 2022 and trades sensitive financial credential transactions. It’s the place where you can buy or sell stolen credit card numbers, SSH login credentials, and personally identifiable information (PII). DWMs are also communication platforms, where users can meet and chat with other users either directly—using Whatsapp, phone, or email—or through specialised forums. We estimate that the trading volume of U2U pairs meeting on DWMs is increasing, reaching a peak in 2020 (during the COVID-19 pandemic).

New payment processing services

The evolution of the multibuyer network follows a similar pattern to the multiseller network until 2015, despite a stronger polarization around Hydra instead of AlphaBay during 2017. However, after the operation Bayonet, although the network shows a decrease in connectivity, it still remains highly connected and with a large number of active multibuyers. Moreover, the network had already fully recovered by 2019 showing a strong resilience against external shocks. While not an onion site, Tor Metrics can provide a fascinating peek “under the hood” of the dark web.

Torzon Market

• As far as financial recourse for victims, some banks and insurance companies have provided payouts and will include those funds as damages in lawsuits against Genesis Market cybercriminals.
• The report reveals that 2023 also saw a rise in the prominence of approval phishing scams.
• (c) Total monthly trading volume sent to all DWMs and exchanged in all unique U2U pairs.
• Among the 40 large DWMs under consideration, 17 participate in at least one transaction in either 2020 or 2021, while the remaining 23 closed before 2020.
• In fact, previous studies on DWM transaction networks have revealed crucial aspects of the ecosystem13,14,15.
• In total, darknet markets and fraud shops received $1.7 billion last year, a rebound from 2022 — the year that saw the sizable Hydra Marketplace close.
• Constant uncertainty, fear of scams, and enforcement pressure create sustained stress.

A thriving category of illicit goods and services sold on dark web markets is that of scans of personal documents. As with our previous reports, we gather data by scanning Dark Web marketplaces, forums, and websites. This information is then processed to generate an index of average prices for a broad range of specific products.

Hacked Online Services & Entertainment Accounts

Users interacting with other users form U2U pairs and we include them in our dataset. We discard single Bitcoin transactions below $0.01 or above $100,000, which are unlikely to show real purchases and minimise false positives. They may be attributed to a residual amount of Bitcoins in an address or transactions between two business partners where no good is actually given in return, respectively. The analysed dataset includes about 31 million transactions among more than 16 million users. If the pair of users interact with multiple DWMs these U2U transactions are included in all related DWMs and counted multiple times. Therefore, the simple sum of all U2U transactions of each DWM is more than the sum of all unique U2U transactions.

Network structure of transactions

• Coins like Bitcoin and Monero have empowered users to conduct transactions without relying on traditional financial systems, enhancing both anonymity and global accessibility.
• The transparency provided by these feedback systems is essential in importing vendor feedback and building trust within the darknet market ecosystem.
• Doing so makes it harder for authorities to identify who’s behind a purchase or a listing.
• Install anti-virus or other anti-malware software on your personal computer to scan for malware.
• It’s the place where you can buy or sell stolen credit card numbers, SSH login credentials, and personally identifiable information (PII).
• The multihomers play a crucial role in the ecosystem because they act as edges between markets.
• Importantly, the algorithm returns reasonable estimates for the number of sellers when compared against a benchmark of nine DWMs where estimates exist.

A once-sizable illicit enterprise that began in 2014, AlphaBay was closed by authorities in 2017 and then reopened in 2021. The last version of the market operated until February of 2023, and a month after that closure, a former AlphaBay vendor pled guilty to distributing fentanyl that caused fatal overdoses in Oregon. The sad reality is the fact that law enforcement agencies can’t track and prosecute perpetrators or even take down such content given the anonymous nature of the dark web.

In 2022 and Q dark web markets continued to bloom with a multitude of listings of various illegal goods and services. In 2023, Chainalysis discovered that some popular fraud shops rely on payment processors as a way to reduce their own costs, add efficiency to their operations, and perhaps add a layer of security to transactions. Genesis Market extensively used a payment processor called UAPS, so much that the processor’s average inflows fell by 25.7% after Genesis closed last April. Regardless, UAPS remains a key provider of payment infrastructure to top fraud shops. Customer reviews found on the Abacus site indicate that some of its American vendors sell drug products laced with fentanyl.

Users in stable pairs meeting both inside and outside DWMs have been growing over the last two years, since the shutdown of AlphaBay9, the largest DWM at the time. In 2020, a total of 6778 pairs of users in stable pairs met inside a DWM, corresponding to 192% of the 2019 level and to 255% of the 2018 level, see Fig. Pairs of users in stable pairs meeting inside a DWM traded for a total of $145 million in 2020, which corresponds to 252% of the 2019 level, and to 593% of the 2018 level, see Fig. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has, however, had different phases, punctuated by the number and level of measures introduced around the world. After that, trading volume sharply increased over the whole of 2020, see Figure S8. The number of stable U2U pairs created each day was, however, steady over time during 2020, even though more U2U pairs were created compared to the same period in 2019, see Figure S9.

The report did, however, present some more positive figures, including a year-over-year decline in revenue from crypto-based scams. Although scams remain one of the biggest drivers of crypto-based crime, with $4.6 billion in revenue for 2023, the figure was down from the previous year’s $5.9 billion. While DeFi adoption among darknet vendors is growing, it has not replaced centralized exchanges as the primary laundering method. However, the trend is clear—illicit actors are expanding their strategies, forcing enforcement agencies to evolve their tracking methods to keep pace with increasingly sophisticated laundering techniques. 7, we show the largest component of the S2S network one year before the operation Bayonet and one year after.

Cointelegraph is committed to providing independent, high-quality journalism across the crypto, blockchain, AI, and fintech industries. To support open access to our website and sustain editorial operations, certain commercial or partner references may appear on our site. These arrangements help maintain an accessible platform and do not result in additional costs to readers.

According to Chainalysis’ 2025 Crypto Crime Report, darknet market (DNM) vendors are adapting their money laundering tactics. While centralized exchanges (CEXs) remain the dominant cash-out method, a notable shift has been toward decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols. We classify all entities either as sellers or buyers as a function of time. The result is a time series of lists of sellers and buyers for each period and for each market and the U2U network.

New websites and forums were created nearly overnight and very quickly filled the gap left by the sites taken down by authorities. This, however, did little to reduce the supply of illicit goods and services on the dark web. Have streamlined the trading darkweb marketplaces process, enhancing user satisfaction and market efficiency. As far as financial recourse for victims, some banks and insurance companies have provided payouts and will include those funds as damages in lawsuits against Genesis Market cybercriminals.

Detection of the U2U network

It’s not as massive as Abacus, but quality’s on point—vendors deliver, and the community’s buzzing on Dread about it. I’ve poked around; it’s not overwhelming, just a tight selection that works—think curated over chaotic. If you’re into a darknet market with a community pulse and solid uptime, Bohemia Dark Market’s climbing the ranks—give it a spin if you like a vibe that’s less corporate, more crew. We showed that a small fraction of traders is responsible for a large fraction of the trading volume, and by analysing the networks of buyers and sellers, we found different resilience regimes. Shocks tend to induce serious structural changes in the multiseller network, but impact the multibuyer network much less severely.

Dark web marketplaces change frequently because they operate under constant pressure from law enforcement, internal fraud, and technical weaknesses. Unlike legal platforms, they have no stable protections or long-term security guarantees. Even if you’ve never visited these markets, your personal and financial data might already be there, having been leaked through a data breach. Criminals use this information for money laundering, opening bank accounts, applying for loans, and draining your finances.